Chapters
Lesson 12: The Useless Tree (for Albert Ayler)
#Blues scale#Diminished chords#Half steps#Triads#Tritone#Whole tone scale#Beginner's mind#Chuang Tzu#Spiritual jazz
This lesson is for Albert Ayler, the spiritual saxophonist, a true friend to joEy from the spiritual world in his darkest times. The song joEy wrote for him at 18 plays at the end, over black.
Chuang Tzu tells of a warped tree nobody wanted for lumber, so it was the only one left standing, and it became the shade. "Ask yourself, what changes in my life from useless to useful, and what could change?"
Quoted on screen, the first read aloud: Albert Ayler, to Nat Hentoff, Down Beat (1966); to Ethel Boros, The Plain Dealer (1967); and his "Message From Albert" on New Grass (1968).
The photographs, credited on screen: Albert as a boy (photographer unknown); the 76th Army Band, Orléans, France, 1959 (Charles W. Taylor); Jazzhus Montmartre, Copenhagen (Jan Persson); the Hilversum Session, 1964 (Ton van Wageningen); De Doelen, Rotterdam, 1966 (Pieter Boersma); the Love Cry session, New York, 1967–68 (Charles Stewart); Brooklyn, 1969 (photographer unknown); the Fondation Maeght, France, 1970 (Jacques Bisceglia).
The lesson is all play, under photographs of Albert from boy to man. joEy plays by sound, not by rules, keeping just one: remember what you played. His ask is a fun one: "Try to pick the worst notes you can. I like to even pretend I'm a kid playing."
Ask joEy
A question about this lesson goes straight to joEy, and it’s always free.
Ask your questionIn this video
- 0:00:11For Albert Ayler
- 0:01:20The Useless Tree
- 0:03:04Advanced Improvisation
- 0:05:46Start Breaking the Rules
- 0:12:28Everything Is Acceptable
- 0:16:41Listen to Albert Ayler
- 0:18:08joEy's Albert Ayler
For Albert Ayler
0:00:11 Hey, this is joEy from Eternal Crane. It's lesson 12. This one is for my good friend Albert Ayler. I've never had a chance to meet Albert. Albert is a spiritual musician. He played the saxophone. I wrote a song for Albert when I was 18 years old. I came home from a party early because I wasn't having a good time. I wrote a song about driving in my car listening to Albert Ayler. It's on one of my early, early records. If you know joEy, you know he's done 24 records at least, full-length records. This goes way back.
0:01:04 Albert Ayler has visited me from the spiritual world, and he's helped me in the most dark times. I don't know what I would do without Albert. Albert's a true friend of mine.
The Useless Tree
0:01:20 So, this is the useless tree. This is Chuang Tzu's useless tree. There's a forest of trees, and all of the wood is precious and good and usable. And there's one tree in the forest that is warped, and it's ugly, and it doesn't fit, and it doesn't belong. And when the lumberjacks come, they chop down every single tree except the one that's warped. The useless tree is the one that survives, and that tree becomes shade when all the other trees get chopped down.
0:02:10 How strange is it that something useless could be the reason that it is useful and is the reason why it survives? So, ask yourself, what changes in my life from useless to useful, and what could change? What do I think is permanent that is actually impermanent? The course is Advanced Improvisations. The lesson, excuse me. And I just have to say, this is one of the most beautiful boys I've ever seen in my life. And I look at this picture, and I just fall in love with music again. I started to play what was in my soul. They heard my cry.
Advanced Improvisation
0:03:04 So, I'm going to do some advanced improvisations, and we're just going to flow. Minor chord. Dominant chord. G minor. F major. 2-4 to 1-3. Flat 7-5-1. I'm just going where my heart takes me. This was a flat 7 triad over the 1 triad. Inverted. I don't know what I did there. I think I played a dominant. I'll have to watch that back. That's dominant. F. Just running down. Inversions.
0:04:04 This is a little chromaticism. This A is a flat 3 in the key of F. See how I'm adding that flat 3? You can take any note and augment it. So, this is how you just play sounds. This is what I want you to do. Minor. Inversions in F minor. F blues. I played the tritone. Twiddle's going to sing. F diminished. Just playing what my heart wants to hear. More.
Start Breaking the Rules
0:05:46 So, start breaking. This is D flat over C. Run. Ending on A flat. 3rds in the left hand. F sharp diminished. I'm sorry. F sharp. Dominants. That was the F sharp chord. Starting on different places and different hands. Dominants. So, just learn to go through all the colors. This is whole tone.
0:06:43 Lovely. That whole tone. I'm going to do the different whole tones. This is so much fun. Picking both whole tones. And they're in different hands. Step apart. Letting it ring. D. I'm going to go B flat. Walk down from B to B flat. A major. Just go down. Why not? See if you're starting to move into advanced. As well. You're starting to move into advanced abstract music. More of this chromatic pattern. Just remember what you played.
0:08:10 Tritone. D tritone. D tritone. E tritone. These are just a triad on the left hand and a block on the right. Back to F. G. G minor. Blues. G minor. Inverted. Missing these pictures of Albert. Now I'll have to watch this again. This little groovy thing. That's just walking down the blues. In the left hand. Inverting. In the right hand. Some hands together. Major.
0:09:38 Do one more. Dominant. Go. This is the diminished. Comfortable. These different colors. Show up somehow. I swear. You'd be surprised. A lot of diminished this time. Thirds. It's the diminished and thirds. Back to the diminished.
Everything Is Acceptable
0:12:28 This is a great way to express yourself. Don't worry. Don't worry if people understand it. I'm just going down. Going down by triads. Half step apart. Anything you can invent. Anything is acceptable. Try to pick the worst notes you can. I like to even pretend I'm a kid playing. Interesting because. A little tricky. You always want to put patterns. So try to find no patterns. Listen to all of these. Go half steps. Half step apart.
0:13:58 The minor in the right hand. Let people make fun of you. You are going to get the benefit. Of listening to all these beautiful sounds. Invert them. Just playing with half steps. Then on the tritone. Listen to that chord. Let's go. Augmented. D major.
0:15:23 You can play D major. Over. Augmented. They're going crazy. They love it. D major. See that little pattern. I'm doing in the left hand. Minor 7-2. Let yourself play like this. See how I just mix that whole tone. Built off D. Just like that. You get some interesting sounds. And you get to express your heart.
Listen to Albert Ayler
0:16:41 That's what Albert Ayler did. He expressed his soul. Please universe. Let me use these photos. I attributed them. I love Albert Ayler so much. I wanted to borrow the photographer's work. As a tribute to Albert. And his beautiful sacred music. I recommend that you listen to Albert Ayler. Please check out his album Ghosts. I'm sorry. It's actually Spiritual Unity. The track is Ghosts. Bells, Prophecy, I recommend. There's so much Albert I would recommend.
0:17:24 Give him a try. And recognize that it's all about expanding the possibilities of the soul. And the mind. And how we can use sound. And that everything is acceptable.
0:17:41 So I hope that's helpful. And thanks for watching. And remember sometimes the most useless things turn out to be the most useful things. So if you're not sure why you would improvise like this. Take a leap of faith. And you'll be shocked to discover what it's going to show you when you're playing next. Alright I'm joEy. I'm going to check out. I'll see you later.
joEy's Albert Ayler
0:18:08 ♪ joEy's song for Albert Ayler, from his early records, 0:18:08–0:20:52
Thirteen Weeks of Music & Spirit Eternal Crane · 12 / 12
- 1
20mOne NoteOctober 6, 2026 - 2
17mLet Music Play YouOctober 8, 2026 - 3
19mLive an Empty Life, Discovering LydianOctober 13, 2026 - 4
20mWrong Notes or Happy AppearancesOctober 15, 2026 - 5
23mNot Knowing Anything is the Best Place to BeginOctober 20, 2026 - 6
22mThe Mountain, 12-Key BluesOctober 22, 2026 - 7
21mThe Human Divinity SignalOctober 27, 2026 - 8
22mThe Husk and the GermOctober 29, 2026 - 9
24mEvery Stranger BelongsNovember 3, 2026 - 10
36mGrace in Every InversionNovember 5, 2026 - 11
29mThe Restless HeartNovember 12, 2026
20mThe Useless Tree (for Albert Ayler)November 19, 2026





